I think you all have made good guesses, but I think Robert hit it on the head when he suggested that the "journalists" are just not comfortable interesting someone who is sort of quiet or shy. when you’re around someone who is quiet, I think the tendency is to just talk more to fill up the uncomfortably empty space. which results in the "interview" turning out more like an op/ed music journalism piece.
the most prepared, tenacious interviewer can still be thrown off by a shy subject. I think music journalism has sort of hit an unprecedented lack of suckage lately because it’s all just a bunch of grandstanding by the "can’t do; teach" crowd– a crowd that almost certainly does not have the patience, attention span, or compassion required for interviewing any talented person of interest.
my solution: knock off the cynical post-ironic questions, knock off the yes-or-no questions, and ask the man something that demands an answer. gear (purple Marshalls
) and spirituality are two great starting points. even the shyest of guitar nerds will happily talk about those two things.
and oh yeah, shut up and listen for the answers.